Finnish Economic Policy Council background report: Lump-sum transfers are the most effective way to address unequal fuel tax burdens to low-income households

Excise taxes on fuels are the most effective way to mitigate road transport emissions in Finland, as they create continuous incentives to reduce annual mileage. However, the burden of the tax is higher on low-income car-owning households. The new background report for the Economic Policy Council analyses various models of compensation. The report is written by doctoral researcher Selina Clarke and the empirical analysis conducted by researcher Kimmo Palanne.
“To sum it up, a lump-sum transfer would compensate costs to low-income households, while not encouraging more driving,” says Clarke.
Low-income car-owners carry relatively high fuel tax burden
When looking at all households, fuel expenditure as a share of income is relatively small, approximately below 4 percent, and is the highest for households in the 6th-8th income deciles. However, when we only look at car-owning households, fuel expenditure as a share of income is considerably higher for low-income households – fuel expenses are over 10 percent for the lowest income decile and below 3 percent for the highest income decile.
A lump-sum transfer is the most effective way to reduce fuel costs
Compensation can effectively even out differences in tax burdens between income deciles. A lump-sum transfer is the most effective way to reduce the burden of taxation in the lowest income deciles. Furthermore, lump-sum transfers are expected to generate fewer environmentally harmful incentives compared to, for example, reductions in fuel taxes. The latter would make driving relatively cheaper.
Conversely, reductions in income or fuel taxes would disproportionately benefit high-income households who drive more and pay more tax.
Based on a comparison of different compensation measures, lump-sum transfers to households appear to be slightly better at reducing distributional effects across income deciles compared to transfers proportional to household size. The more strongly the compensation is tied to household size, the more households in higher income deciles benefit, because they tend to be larger. Furthermore, lump-sum transfers are also likely to involve lower administrative costs.
“As an example of the lump-sum transfer, households in some Canadian provinces receive a state tax refund four times per year. The refund is paid from the province's carbon dioxide tax revenue,” says Palanne.
The analysis utilises the Finnish Transport Safety Agency Traficom’s data (2016) to determine vehicle owners and each car’s annual distance driven in kilometres. Secondly, using Statistics Finland’s FOLK-dataset, it was possible to assign car owners to households and calculate each household’s total fuel costs and their ratio to household disposable income. In 2016, a total of €1,295 million petrol excise taxes and €1,362 million diesel excise taxes were collected. The estimated revenue from the carbon tax components was 809.7 million euros.The tax refunds modeled in the report are based on distributing this carbon tax revenue.
The Council publishes an annual report for 2022 evaluating recent economic policy decisions on Wednesday February 1st. Green transition is one of the of the topics of the report seminar.
Contacts
Kimmo PalanneResearcherVATT / Energy, climate and environmental policy
Tel:+358 295 519 521kimmo.palanne@vatt.fiSelina ClarkeDoctoral researcherUniversity of Helsinki / Economics
selina.clarke@helsinki.fiImages
Documents
About Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvosto (TPAN)
The Finnish Economic Policy Council was established in 2014 to provide independent evaluation of the objectives of economic policy and the effectiveness of the policy measures chosen. Through its work, the Council aims to improve the quality of economic policy decision-making and preparatory work, and to bring an independent and research-based perspective to the public discussion on economic policy.
Subscribe to releases from Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvosto (TPAN)
Subscribe to all the latest releases from Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvosto (TPAN) by registering your e-mail address below. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Latest releases from Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvosto (TPAN)
Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvosto: Nykyisessä suhdannetilanteessa ei ole perusteita lykätä julkisen talouden sopeutustoimia14.4.2023 07:00:00 EEST | Tiedote
Suomen julkisessa taloudessa on edelleen kestävyysongelma, jonka pienentämisen tulisi olla yksi seuraavan hallituksen tavoitteista. Julkisen talouden vahvistamiseen tähtäävät veronkorotukset ja menoleikkaukset on syytä pyrkiä ajoittamaan niin, että ne tukevat vakaata talouskehitystä.
Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvoston taustaraportti: Suomen satsaukset vihreisiin innovaatioihin ovat laskussa4.4.2023 07:26:26 EEST | Tiedote
Suomi on ollut asukaslukuun suhteutettuna yksi maailman eniten innovoivia maita. Suomen T&K-panostukset ovat kuitenkin laskeneet viimeisen kymmenen vuoden aikana. Tänä aikana innovaatioiden patentointi kokonaisuudessaan ja yllättäen myös ympäristöteknologioiden patentointi on laskenut. Paras tieto teknologisen kehityksen mahdollisuuksista on yrityksillä itsellään. Siksi on ensi sijassa pidettävä huoli siitä, että tutkimukselle ja kehitykselle otolliset yhteiskunnan rakenteet ja rahoitus ovat kunnossa.
Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvosto asetettiin neljän vuoden toimikaudeksi3.2.2023 13:41:16 EET | Uutinen
Valtioneuvosto asetti talouspolitiikan arviointineuvoston toimikaudelle 1.4.2023–31.3.2027. Neuvoston tavoitteena on parantaa talouspoliittisen päätöksenteon ja sen valmistelun laatua, avoimuutta ja ymmärrettävyyttä.
Ekonomipolitiskt råd: Nästa regering behöver en trovärdig plan för skattepolitisk anpassning och för att bekämpa klimatförändringarna1.2.2023 10:00:00 EET | Tiedote
Covid-19-pandemin och den aktuella krisen har visat hur viktigt det är att regeringen klarar av att stimulera ekonomin. Med hänsyn till det långvariga underskottet i de offentliga finanserna bör den nya regeringens mandatperiod inledas med en trovärdig plan för skattepolitisk anpassning. Den allt stramare klimatpolitiken runtom i EU kommer även att påverka Finland.
Talouspolitiikan arviointineuvosto: Seuraavan hallituksen on luotava uskottava suunnitelma talouden vakauttamiseksi ja ilmastonmuutoksen torjumiseksi1.2.2023 10:00:00 EET | Tiedote
Pandemia ja Ukrainassa puhjennut sota ovat osoittaneet, että talouspolitiikan kyky tukea taloutta on tärkeää. Talouden pysyvän alijäämän johdosta uuden hallituksen tulisi aloittaa sopeutussuunnitelman toteuttaminen heti kautensa alussa. Euroopan tiukentuvilla ilmastotavoitteilla tulee olemaan taloudellisia vaikutuksia myös Suomelle.
In our pressroom you can read all our latest releases, find our press contacts, images, documents and other relevant information about us.
Visit our pressroom